Review: Elemental

Elemental is an unusual publication for several reasons. Firstly, I can’t remember ever having come
across an anthology that doesn’t have an introduction from the editor or editors. Secondly, it’s an
anthology of translated fiction—rare enough in itself—not assembled according to country, region,
generation, gender or genre but rather the fairly amorphous concept of the “elements”, a category that
might just as easily encompass ancient mystical whimsy as hard-nosed scientific data. Thirdly, these
reticent editors appear to have (very laudably) gone out of their way to track down texts that weren’t
previously available—a little detective work from the copyright page suggests that only Ankomst, by
the Norwegian writer Gøhril Gabrielsen has been previously published in English, by Peirene
Press—and more disorienting still, only a couple seem to be a stand-alone texts, most are taken from a
longer piece. They all begin and end rather abruptly.

Several aspects of the above paragraph might be enough to give prospective readers pause but
that would be a shame: when was the last time, even in the company of the most surly bookseller or
librarian that you could honestly say that you’ve picked up a book with no idea what to expect? Such is
the experience of beginning Elemental; we’re entirely at the mercy of this assortment of writers and
translators. The good news is that in spite, or because, of our fug of ignorance there’s plenty of treasure
to be found.

If there’s a common theme to most of these very different texts it is, unsurprisingly in these
crisis-stricken times, a heavy emphasis on humanity’s tinkering/altering/ravaging of the natural world.
In Japan, we’re concerned with radiation, on a remote island in the north Atlantic we’re monitoring
plunging seabird populations, Madagascar is being burned to a crisp to further urban expansion… you
get the idea, but while the urgency of each of these texts is tangible one never feels the victim of
environmental agitprop. It’s entirely natural for these writers’ characters to be concerned with these
issues because they’re issues that worry a vast proportion of the global population, ones that really
ought to worry its entirety.

This collection, however, isn’t actually about the bigger picture, it was instead conceived with a
much narrower focus in mind: as a befits a publication from the imprint of the Center for the Art of
Translation, its mission is to show, by removing these texts from their natural habitats and plonking
them on a stage devoid of context with no illumination but the harsh gaze of the quizzical reader, just
how good translations can be. And I’m very pleased to report that the exercise is remarkably

Stand out pieces for me include Erika Kobayashi’s extraordinary story Precious Stones,
written in the tradition of uncanny realism by Japanese women writers that makes one wonder why
people insist on raving about Haruki Murakami, Andreas Moster’s We Have Lived Here Since We Were
Born, especially the climactic quarry scene, and Tamar Weiss-Gabbay’s The Weather Woman, which
contains a surprisingly compelling argument for eating rocks, but others might prefer the comic
whimsy of Bakhityar Ali’s flying dissident in Jamshid Khan, or the melancholy lyricism of Michèle
Rakotoson’s Lalana. What’s not up for debate is the quality and consistency of each of the translations,
which evoke their writers’ voices without ever trying to impersonate them, something that is greatly to
the credit of the translators, of course, but also those gnomic editors.

Elemental is published by Two Lines Press and is part of the Calico Series.

Review written by Kit Maude
Kit Maude is a translator based in Buenos Aires. He has translated dozens of Latin American writers for a wide array of publications and writes reviews and criticism for several different outlets in Spanish and English.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: